Can I Keep Him?

Can I Keep Him?: This achievement requires you to collect a certain amount of vanity pets. Vanity pets are the little out of combat pets that you can summon and have follow you around. The first achievement requires you to collect 1 pet, the second 25 pets, third 50 pets and fourth 75 pets. When you reach 50 pets, you will also receive a [Reeking Pet Carrier]. When you reach 75 pets you will receive [Little Fawn's Salt Lick].

Below is a complete list of every vanity pet in the game. (Thanks to Breanni for this guide)

Vendor Items (Both Factions):

[ ] Ghostly Skull (Dalaran)
[ ] Blue Dragonhawk Hatchling (Netherstorm)
[ ] Brown Rabbit Cage (Netherstorm)
[ ] Cat Carrier (Siamese) (Netherstorm
[ ] Mana Wyrmling (Netherstorm)
[ ] Red Moth Egg (Netherstorm)
[ ] Cockroach (Netherstorm)
[ ] Crimson Snake (Netherstorm)
[ ] Parrot Cage (Cockatiel) (Booty Bay)
[ ] Parrot Cage (Senegal) (Booty Bay)
[ ] Ancona Chicken (Thousand Needles)

Vendor Items (Alliance):

[ ] Rabbit Crate (Snowshoe) (Dun Morogh)
[ ] Cat Carrier (Bombay) (Elwynn Forest)
[ ] Cat Carrier (Cornish Rex) (Elwynn Forest)
[ ] Cat Carrier (Orange Tabby) (Elwynn Forest)
[ ] Cat Carrier (Silver Tabby) (Elwynn Forest)
[ ] Cat Carrier (White Kitten) (Stormwind City)
[ ] Great Horned Owl (Teldrassil)
[ ] Hawk Owl (Teldrassil)
[ ] Blue Moth Egg (Exodar)
[ ] White Moth Egg (Exodar)
[ ] Yellow Moth Egg (Exodar)

Vendor Items (Horde):

[ ] Golden Dragonhawk Hatchling (Eversong Woods)
[ ] Red Dragonhawk Hatchling (Eversong Woods)
[ ] Silver Dragonhawk Hatchling (Eversong Woods)
[ ] Black Kingsnake (Orgrimmar)
[ ] Brown Snake (Orgrimmar)
[ ] Prairie Dog Whistle (Thunder Bluff)

Crafts:

[ ] Mechanical Squirrel Box (Engineering)
[ ] Tranquil Mechanical Yeti (Engineering)
[ ] Lifelike Mechanical Toad (Engineering)
[ ] Lil'Smoky (Gnomish Engineering)
[ ] Pet Bombling (Goblin Engineering)

Quest Rewards:

[ ] Sprite Darter Egg (Ally Only, Feralas)
[ ] Chicken Egg (Ally Only, Westfall)
[ ] Mechanical Chicken (Booty Bay)
[ ] Miniwing (Terokkar Forest)
[ ] Smolderweb Carrier (LBRS)
[ ] Worg Carrier (LBRS)

Fishing Daily Quest Reward Items (Terokkar Forest):

[ ] Chuck's Bucket
[ ] Muckbreath's Bucket
[ ] Snarly's Bucket
[ ] Toothy's Bucket

Reputation Rewards:

[ ] Nether Ray Fry (Skyguard)
[ ] Tiny Sporebat (Sporeggar)
[ ] Nutured Penguin Egg (The Kalu'ak)
[ ] Cobra Hatchling (The Oracles)
[ ] Proto-Drake Whelp (The Oracles)
[ ] Tickbird Hatchling (The Oracles)
[ ] White Tickbird Hatchling (The Oracles)

Achievement Rewards:

[ ] Reeking Pet Carrier (Shop Smart, Shop Pet..... Smart)
[ ] Kirin Tor Familiar (Higher Learning)

Drops:

[ ] Azure Whelpling (Azshara)
[ ] Captured Firefly (Zangarmarsh)
[ ] Cat Carrier (Black Tabby) (Silverpine Forest, Horde Only)
[ ] Dark Whelpling (Dustwallow Marsh)
[ ] Disgusting Oozeling (Felwood)
[ ] Parrot Cage (Green Wing Macaw) (Deadmines)
[ ] Parrot Cage (Hyacinth Macaw) (STV)
[ ] Phoenix Hatchling (Magister's Terrace)
[ ] Tiny Crimson Whelpling (Wetlands)
[ ] Tiny Emerald Whelpling (Swamp of Sorrows)
[ ] Sprite Darter Hatchling (Feralas)
[ ] Strand Crawler (Fishing Dailies)

Special Drops:

[ ] Mojo (Zul'Aman)
[ ] Magical Crawdad Box (Fishing, Mr. Pinchy)
[ ] Giant Sewer Rat (Fishing, Dalaran's Underbelly)

World Event Items:

[ ] Wolpertinger's Tankard (Brewfest)
[ ] Egbert's Egg (Children's Week)
[ ] Elekk Training Collar (Children's Week)
[ ] Piglet's Collar (Children's Week)
[ ] Rat Cage (Children's Week)
[ ] Sleepy Willy (Children's Week)
[ ] Turtle Box (Children's Week)
[ ] A Jubling's Tiny Home (Darkmoon Faire)
[ ] Tree Frog Box (Darkmoon Faire)
[ ] Wood Frog Box (Darkmoon Faire)
[ ] Sinister Squashling (Hallows End)
[ ] Truesilver Shafted Arrow (Love Is In The Air)
[ ] Scorched Stone (Midsummer Fire Festival)
[ ] Captured Flame (Midsummer Fire Festival)
[ ] Green Helper Box (Winter Veil)
[ ] Jingling Bell (Winter Veil)
[ ] Red Helper Box (Winter Veil)
[ ] Snowman Kit (Winter Veil)

Special Event Items:

[ ] Baby Blizzard Bear (Anniversary 08 Only)
[ ] Clockwork Rocket Bot (Winter Veil 07)
[ ] Gold Medallion (Olympics 08)
[ ] Vampiric Batling (WoTLK Launch event)

Exclusive Items:

[ ] Blue Murloc Egg (Blizzcon)
[ ] Diablo Stone (Classic Collector's Edition)
[ ] Panda Collar (Classic Collector's Edition)
[ ] Zergling Leash (Classic Collector's Edition)
[ ] Netherwhelp's Collar (The Burning Crusade CE)
[ ] Lurky's Egg (European TBC CE)
[ ] Frosty's Collar (WoTLK CE)
[ ] Pink Murloc Egg (Contest)
[ ] Competitor's Souvenir (Olympics)
[ ] Golden Pin Coin (Promotional)
[ ] Green Dragon Orb (Promotional)
[ ] Polar Bear Collar (Promotional)
[ ] Red Dragon Orb (Promotional)
[ ] Silver Pig Coin (Promotional)
[ ] Fortune Coin (Worldwide Invitational)
[ ] Tyrael's Hilt (Worldwide Invitational)
[ ] Banana Charm (TCG)
[ ] Dragon Kite (TCG)
[ ] Hippogryph Hatchling (TCG)
[ ] Rocket Chicken (TCG)
[ ] Soul-Trader Beacon (TCG)